Healy’s Tavern No ratings yet. Posted June 23, 2011 374 Newark Avenue Jersey City, NJ 07302 (201) 222-2777 Website Our Two Cents We have yet to experience the pleasure of stopping by for a sip. Get the ball rolling and contact us to let us know you need a visit and review! Rate this bar Bar Rating Scarecrow This is the best bar downtown. Its perfect. No where better for afternoon drinks, which are my favorite. susansaint I was there last night, loved the wide round bar. You can drink and eat at the bar. It’s great, relaxed, not stuffy, and everyone is friendly. Sweaterfish Yes! Cutest bartenders I’ve ever seen, so cute that my husband left me for one for them. Great place! sully I’ve been in quite a few times since they opened and here are my opinions thus far. They did a nice job with the renovation, completely gutted Shelia’s and put in a nice horse shoe shaped bar. The outside is a work in progress and hopefully a bike rack will be installed. 4 beers currently on tap, Coors Lt, Yuengling, Guinness and Blue Moon and more in the bottle. (get there for happy hour, cheap beers & cute bartenders!) Menu is very basic but good, I’ve tried the wings, burger, cheese steak and hot dogs, they also have corned beef sandwiches and chicken fingers on the menu. The burger was good, fresh and not a frozen Sysco puck. The cheese steak was actually a cut of steak and not steakums which I expected for the price. The wings are ok (I’m a wing snob) and the hot dogs are delicious. I haven’t had an opportunity to check out the corned beef though, it was sold out the last time I asked for it. Overall, the menu is decent and affordably priced. As for staff, Pat and Jerry are very affable behind the bar, I had never met them before they opened but they’ve quickly learned my name and drink. Summing it all up, it’s a nice addition to the neighborhood and an upgrade over Shelia’s.